The author, who describes herself as a “bag connoisseur” and a serial overpacker, evaluated each backpack on aesthetics, waterproofing, durability, capacity, laptop compatibility and comfort under load. She also recorded price points to gauge value for money.
The Kapten & Son Tromso All‑Black backpack emerged as the overall winner. Priced at £99, it offers a 12‑litre capacity, multiple compartments including an anti‑theft pouch, a padded laptop sleeve for a 13‑inch MacBook Air, and a water‑repellent finish. Reviewers praised its sleek design, lightweight feel and the ability to attach buggy straps, though the matte surface can show fingerprints.
For shoppers on a tighter budget, the New Look Black Faux‑Leather Rectangle Zip Pocket Backpack was highlighted as the best value at £29.99. It features a padded laptop insert, front and interior pockets, and a stylish faux‑leather texture. The reviewer warned that the straps are slim and may snap under heavy, repeated use, and the material is not water‑repellent.
The New Balance Wayfinder Pack earned the “best for compartments” label with a £90 price tag. Its six external pockets, large padded laptop sleeve and comfortable wide straps make it a strong candidate for commuters and gym‑goers. Although not marketed as water‑repellent, it performed well in a drizzly September test.
Other notable mentions included the Antler Urban Light Backpack, praised for its travel‑friendly 17‑litre capacity and suitcase‑style flap; the Fabletics Sleek Backpack, which offers a 35‑litre roll‑top design with water‑repellent fabric; and the Cambridge Satchel Portrait Backpack, a handcrafted leather option that combines classic style with modern functionality.
Across the board, reviewers stressed the importance of checking strap durability, water‑resistance claims and the presence of secure closures, especially for bags intended for commuting on the London Underground or for outdoor travel.
The roundup concludes that while personal style will dictate the final choice, the Kapten & Son Tromso provides the most balanced mix of looks, practicality and durability for the modern woman, with the New Look and New Balance models offering strong alternatives for specific budget or organisational needs.